Behind the Price Tag: Cake & Dessert

“Couldn’t we just have a friend bake it?” Or, “Let’s skip the cake and do a few cute pastries.” Sensible thoughts—until delivery windows, display rentals, and per-slice fees show up on the invoice. Cake (and its chic cousins) isn’t just flour and sugar; it’s design, food safety, transport, styling, and service.

Below is what’s realistic for a micro-wedding of ~50 guests—with ranges, hidden costs, and smart ways to make it look luxe without overspending.

A rustic autumn wedding cake adorned with figs, pistachios, and olive branches, beautifully capturing the essence of the season.

The “We’ll DIY Dessert” Idea

Buying ingredients and baking the week of your wedding sounds charming. In practice:

• Ingredients + tools: $150–$450 for quality butter, chocolate, fruit, pans, boxes, supports, and a thermometer.

• Storage: you’ll need real refrigeration space; home fridges fight odors and humidity.

• Time: 8–14 hours across mixing, baking, cooling, frosting, and boxing—during your final countdown.

• Day-of logistics: who transports, assembles, and styles the table while you’re in hair and makeup?

Micro-wedding reality: DIY rarely saves once you price tools, transport, and stress. If you love baking, consider one small “cutting cake” and purchase the rest from a professional.

What Professionals Actually Charge

You’re paying for food safety, technique, and seamless day-of execution. For 50 guests:

Classic Wedding Cake (buttercream)

• Two-tier buttercream (clean finish): $350–$700(Think 6”+8” or 6”+9” tiers; 50–60 servings depending on slice style.)

• Design upgrades: +$100–$400 for textures, painted buttercream, metallic leaf, or fresh florals (often supplied by your florist).

• Fondant / sugar-flower work: add $200–$600—it’s couture labor.

Dessert Bar Alternatives

• Plan 2–3 mini pieces per guest for a light finish.

  • Petits fours, tartlets, brownies, profiteroles: $2–$5 each

  • Macarons: $2–$3 each

  • Cupcakes: $3–$5 each

  • Small “cutting cake” for the photo moment: $75–$200

• For 50 guests at 2 pieces each: $200–$500 for the sweets themselves; styled displays typically land $400–$900 once you add variety, packaging, and rentals.

Delivery & Setup

• Local delivery + setup: $50–$150 (more for difficult access, long distances, or venue load-in rules).

• Tastings: $25–$50 per couple (often credited to the order).

• Stands & risers: $15–$75 each to rent; statement pedestals can be $100+.

• Fresh floral accents: $40–$150 (sourced by florist or baker—confirm who provides and who places).

A lavish dessert bar adorned with an exquisite array of chocolates, truffles, and assorted sweets set against lush greenery and vibrant floral arrangements.

Hidden Costs Couples Miss

• Cutting or plating fee: venues often charge $1.50–$3 per slice (yes, even for cupcakes or outside desserts).

• Dietary accommodations: vegan/gluten-free often add 10–20%.

• Refrigeration on site: some venues require earlier delivery; bakers may charge for wait time.

• Late-night service: additional staffing or tray-pass fees.

• Returns: someone must return rented stands the next day (or pay a pickup fee).

• Cake from an outside vendor in restaurants: confirm corkage-style policies for desserts.

Where to Splurge (and Where to Save)

Splurge

• The finish that shows in photos: a flawless buttercream, a single sugar-flower spray, or a hand-painted motif.

• A beautiful stand + styled vignette (candles, linen, a few repurposed florals). The scene matters as much as the pastry.

Save

• Choose buttercream over fondant.

• Order a smaller display cake and have the kitchen cut from a matching sheet in the back.

• Do two flavors max; every extra flavor means extra mise en place and cost.

• Seasonal fruit and textures (pressed florals, stucco buttercream) read editorial without couture pricing.

• Repurpose ceremony flowers to the cake table.

• Set sweets as a late-night moment; you can reduce quantity when guests are full.

Real-World Budgets (50 Guests)

• Editorial buttercream two-tier + simple florals, delivered: $350–$700

• Cutting cake + mini dessert bar (2 pieces/guest): $400–$900

• Luxe fondant or hand-crafted sugar florals: $800–$1,600

• Add venue cutting/plating if applicable: +$75–$150 total

Prices vary by market, design complexity, and delivery logistics—use these as planning bands, then confirm with vendors.

Questions to Ask Your Baker (copy/paste)

1. Servings: How many true wedding slices does this size yield? (Coffee vs. dessert portions.)

2. Design: What’s included in the base price vs. an add-on (textures, metallics, sugar flowers)?

3. Delivery & setup: Cost, timing, who places florals, and who handles stand returns.

4. Venue policies: Are cutting/plating fees typical here? Will you coordinate with the venue directly?

5. Storage: Will the cake be refrigerated on site? How long can it sit displayed?

6. Dietary needs: Vegan/GF options and surcharges; how are allergens handled?

7. Tasting & payment: Is the tasting credited? What’s the deposit/last-payment schedule?

8. Plan B: If heat/humidity/transport is risky, what’s the protective plan?

Reality Check

Dessert is a memory moment—your names whispered over candlelight, a quiet cheer as the knife lifts, the first bite. Whether it’s a slim two-tier or a tightly edited dessert bar, one beautiful vignette feels custom and photographs like a dream. Think: creamy finish, candle glow, a handful of florals, and a confident “less, but better” edit.

Pro Lovestruck Tip

Create a portrait-ready cake scene: a linen runner, layered pedestals, low votives, and your bouquet nearby. Ask your photographer to schedule five calm minutes for the cut—no announcements, just a private toast while the room softens around you. Guests remember the mood, not the slice count.

Ready to plan your own small celebration? Join our list and get the free 2-page Micro-Wedding Starter Checklist →